Who is the greatest soccer player of all time? The main candidates

The greatest-of-all-time debate never ends because there is no single measure of greatness. Comparing players across eras means weighing trophies, statistics, influence and style. Here are the criteria people use and the facts behind the main candidates.

Who is the greatest soccer player of all time? The main candidates
Credit : whatcanu.com

How to compare

  • Trophies: World Cups, continental titles, league titles, Champions League wins.
  • Individual awards: the Ballon d’Or and FIFA awards.
  • Statistics: goals and assists, while remembering that positions and eras differ.
  • Longevity: performing at the top for many seasons.
  • Influence: how a player changed the way the game is played or perceived.

The main candidates

Pelé (Brazil): won three World Cups (1958, 1962, 1970), the only player to do so, and scored prolifically for Santos.

Diego Maradona (Argentina): led Argentina to the 1986 World Cup, including his famous solo goal against England, and took Napoli to two Serie A titles.

Lionel Messi (Argentina): a record eight Ballon d’Or awards, many trophies with Barcelona, and the 2022 World Cup with Argentina.

Cristiano Ronaldo (Portugal): five Ballon d’Or awards, Champions League wins with Manchester United and Real Madrid, and the record for most goals in men’s international football.

Who is the greatest soccer player of all time? The main candidates
Credit : whatcanu.com

Johan Cruyff (Netherlands): three Ballon d’Or awards, the face of “Total Football”, and later a hugely influential coach at Barcelona.

Alfredo Di Stéfano: the driving force of the Real Madrid team that won the first five European Cups (1956 to 1960).

Marta (Brazil): six-time FIFA World Player of the Year and the all-time top scorer at World Cups, men’s or women’s, with 17 goals.

The context problem

Players from earlier eras played on poorer pitches, with less protection from referees, less sports science and less television coverage. Modern players face denser schedules and more tactical analysis. Statistics can mislead when compared across such different conditions.

Form your own view

Decide which criteria matter most to you, then watch full matches, not just highlights. For books and documentaries that help, see the best resources to learn about soccer.

Leave a Comment